Both My PS4 Mic and My USB Mic pick up my voice.

[Brax2Raw]

So I have a Blue Yeti USB mic connected to my PC for recording commentary, I also have Astro A40 mic to hear game sound and talk to my friends in party chat. When I'm recording by myself I just mute my PS4 mic and it records the game sound while the blue yeti records my voice. but when i want to record and talk to my friends i have to unmute my mic and it picks up both my Yeti and my Astros when i talk. is there a way around this? I use OBS Studio